I would give it 6/10 as movie.
As for berserk fan 3/10.
It does well the parts that it has close to manga (but is never faithful as much as anime) which adds to a few key scenes:
- Assassination
- Fight scenes between Guts and Griffith
- Water fountain scene between Griffith and Charlotte.
It was beautiful in animation compared to the anime. But it was very bad in a few scenes with the CG which was disappointing and looked like a video game cutscene while game was freezing up on you.
I like the animation of Guts and Casca. I guess they made Casca have lighter skin color of the manga of Casca after the eclipse which wasn't too bad.
They cut way too much out of key key moments and too little of a starting point movie to get people familiar with Berserk.
As for berserk fan 3/10.
It does well the parts that it has close to manga (but is never faithful as much as anime) which adds to a few key scenes:
- Assassination
- Fight scenes between Guts and Griffith
- Water fountain scene between Griffith and Charlotte.
It was beautiful in animation compared to the anime. But it was very bad in a few scenes with the CG which was disappointing and looked like a video game cutscene while game was freezing up on you.
I like the animation of Guts and Casca. I guess they made Casca have lighter skin color of the manga of Casca after the eclipse which wasn't too bad.
They cut way too much out of key key moments and too little of a starting point movie to get people familiar with Berserk.