But, by the same standards of speculation you say it’s proof that Guts’ is connected with Elves? So, how come you don’t believe that (and NEVER will), but you so adamantly believe he’s part Elf?
That’s my point Paradise, I don’t think Guts is related to God Hand, but it is much more likely than him being part Elf, if you look at it unbiased. Anyway, since you brought up important themes disappearing from the story, what about Guts' struggle to triumph over the God Hand as a mere human, the significance of that would be totally lost if he were part Elf.
Logic and imagination aren’t mutually exclusive, the same thing goes for surprise; the sacrifice of the Hawks made perfect sense. My point about logic is that your contradict yourself on this subject frequently.
Whoa, the fact that he’s linked to Elves?! So you say, but I already discredited all the things you claim suggested Guts was Elvin with facts from the manga, you are ignoring the things that contradict you idea.
Don’t bother, just re-read my post where I explained the flaws in your points.
I agree, but...
...why did you say this before, you seem to disagree with yourself?
That’s why were still debating this, I don’t care what your personal belief is, but you make things up and present them like they are a basic part of the story. And now you’ve even created a paradox with your theory; you’re basically saying the elves Guts are related to are a race of elves Miura hasn’t even introduced into the series, meaning all you’re “evidence” that point’s to Puck’s race isn’t even applicable?! In essence, even you’re theory states that Guts is not related to the elves seen in Berserk but to some other elves that currently don’t exist.
Okay, you contradicted yourself in less than twenty words. Just the very fact that Guts knows Puck superficially “links” him to elves. And you’ve said he’s “Half-Elf” or “Part-Elf” at least half a dozen times (including above!), even going as far as saying that Guts’ father may be some kind of Elf.
Okay, the answer is that Skull Knight is linked to elves and Guts knows him, this in no way makes Guts an elf by association. Also, the fact that Puck hasn’t sensed anything Elvin about Guts infers that Guts isn’t part elf at all, it blatantly goes against you’re theory and you just don’t acknowledge it.
That’s not the theory you’ve been talking about all this time, you’ve been saying Guts is some kind of Elf-Man hybrid and that Guts' father might be from some kind of Elf race (apparently besides Puck’s). You also have cited that particular idea as a reason why Guts is so powerful, a sentiment shared by this theory. The problems I have with this one are the same as with the Elf-Man theory: First, it has no real basis in the story; nothing that directly supports the idea, and secondly there are things in the story that contradict or go against it. For example, it still doesn’t explain why Puck doesn’t sense all this Elvin power Guts is endowed with.
Fine, I have no problem whatsoever thinking of this like a test. Probably because my answers are based on facts from the manga and they don’t blatantly contradict each other. Also, if my facts didn’t add up I would simply concede so as not to make a fool of myself out of irrational pride or blind faith in my personal beliefs. Plus, not only do I have a proven answer to all those questions that makes sense, but it’s the same simple answer to each question: Because nothing in the manga suggests that Guts is part Elf.